The Mystery! The Intrigue!

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

I forgot about this.

[Jeff Ross]

How mysterious…

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

How intriguing…

[Manalive Smith]

Who won?

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

I do believe Franklin did.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Updated poll that includes the vote-getters from the previous poll in addition to some other people.
http://www.strawpoll.me/14267718

[Awkward Potato]

I have voted.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

There were too many good options.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Hm, who voted “other?”

[DScott]

Not me.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Interesting.

[me]

That is true.

[Masøn M.]

I voted Noodle cause I still think he’s most mysterious…

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

You?
Wait, do we know that it’s a he?

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Let me rephrase that: Do YOU know that it’s a he?

[Awkward Potato]

…I just realized something. Matthew’s nickname on the group chat used to be Noodle…it could be a false lead, but whob knows

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Interesting. Very interesting. I should review their comments.
Also, it was pointed out that I forgot Messy_Sparrow. Though I’ve seen them in Inner Tube comments before, too.

[Awkward Potato]

Yeah, I was going to mention Messy_Sparrow as well.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

All these people that have commented less than 5 times…

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

I forgot that Noodle named their thread “MATHS, MY DUDE.”

[Awkward Potato]

Haha yeah. How many do we have with fewer than five comments?

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Watermelon is at around 5 at this point, if I’m remembering correctly Noodle commented 3 or 4 times, Messy_Sparrow was just once, Lista Rose once (though we later found out that she’s Manalive, Peter, and JFF’s sister), Slick Pickle was once or twice, I think there may have been somebody else somewhere in the depths of the story game… plus Ryan, but I don’t think he really counts.

[Awkward Potato]

Ryan hasn’t commented more than five times? But yeah, he probably doesn’t count. The only other one I can think of is the Phantom.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

No, I think it’s only once on the Not-Forum. True, but I’m relatively sure of their identity.

[DScott]

Where can I find Slick Pickle comments? I must know how many comments this individual has made, and whether they were at all recent.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

It seems Pickle commented twice.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Once Upon a Time, Part 1

[DScott]

I see. It was somewhat recent, and even in a place the comments won’t be merely swallowed up amongst the others to be forgotten.

[Jeff Ross]

Olive is a member of TOPHAT (without a title) with exactly five comments on the thread (all on the first page), but I’m not sure where else she appears in the Not-Forum.

[Josiah the Carrot Stick]

Correct.

[Author]

Posts